Why state tax courts are peachy
31 December 2024

Georgia’s creation of a state tax court is important news. It’s a welcome development for companies and indirect tax groups that operate in the Peach State for several reasons.
Dedicated state tax courts tend to be helmed by judges who possess specialised expertise in tax matters, and this tends to lead to more favourable legal outcomes for taxpayers. The opposite is true when general jurisdiction courts (e.g., division, superior and appeals courts) handle tax-related legal disputes.
The law firm Eversheds Sutherland publishes a quarterly “SALT Scoreboard” that tallies the outcomes for what it deems to be “significant” taxpayer wins and losses in legal disputes involving corporate income, franchise tax and sales and use taxes. The results are rarely, if ever, favorable to taxpayers. During Q3 of this year, taxpayers prevailed in only 33% (seven out of 21) of these legal disputes. For the year to date, the tally is 30 wins for taxpayers and 65 losses. In disputes involving sales and use taxes this year, taxpayers have so far lost 25 out of 32 cases.
Keep in mind that the majority of these tax cases are heard in courts of general jurisdiction – not in specialized state tax courts, in which taxpayers typically have much higher success rates (as high as 50% to 65%). Higher success rates are a compelling reason why state tax courts are a better venue for taxpayers to resolve sales and use tax disputes; other advantages include:
- More detailed and nuanced judicial guidance: Given their depth of tax knowledge and experience, state tax court judges tend to issue more thorough and substantive guidance. Their opinions tend to be more detailed and technically sound from a tax policy perspective while recognising the interfaces among state, local, and federal taxing jurisdictions.
- Stronger settlement leverage: Given that taxpayers are more likely to prevail in state tax court cases, Department of Revenue administrators tend to give more thought and effort to reaching a settlement with taxpayers rather than allowing the dispute to go to court. In other words, higher taxpayer success rates create a stronger incentive for resolution.
- More likely to manage compliance and business complexity: As tax policy evolves to address e-commerce, marketplace facilitator tax determinations and emerging forms of digital commerce, specialised expertise is needed to understand and rule on disputes related to interstate transactions and difficult nexus issues.
While Georgia’s adoption of a specialised state tax court is promising news for companies that do business there, it also provides a blueprint for other states to consider following.
Disclaimer
Please remember that the Vertex blog provides information for educational purposes, not specific tax or legal advice. Always consult a qualified tax or legal advisor before taking any action based on this information. The views and opinions expressed in the Vertex blog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy, position or opinion of Vertex, Inc.
Blog Author
Michael Bernard is the Chief Tax Officer of Transaction Tax. In his role, he provides insight and thought leadership around tax department operations, U.S. indirect tax, tax risk management, and tax policy, as well as emerging tax trends. He is an executive-level tax attorney with a diverse portfolio of experience in corporate tax, administration, and finance, including a substantive knowledge of U.S. and international tax laws.
Prior to joining Vertex, Michael was in various tax leadership roles at Microsoft Corporation for 28 years, the most recent being Senior Director – Tax Counsel. Michael led teams in the following functional areas: direct and indirect tax controversy, sales and use, business license, property, tax IT, SOX, and telecommunications. He also co-led a corporate taxpayer advocacy group with the Washington Department of Revenue and was a Director on the Board of the Washington Research Council. Michael has also testified before administrative and lawmakers at both the federal and state level.
Michael earned both a J.D. and a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration from Creighton University. He is a part-time lecturer of Law in the LLM program at the University of Washington School of Law. Michael also served on the board of directors, executive committee, and chaired committees for The Tax Executives Institute (TEI) for nearly 25 years.

